Amy L. Diestelhorst, MD

Remove | Saved Doctors ()
OB/GYN, Primary Care
4.9 (239)
Best Doctors logo
Staff Physician
Accepting New Patients

Call for an appointment

Town Hall Health Center (262) 532-3600
View MoreLess
Germantown Health Center (262) 253-5060

My goal is to provide comprehensive and compassionate care to women in various stages of their lives - from adolescence to adulthood, during pregnancy and during menopause. I strive to assist women to make optimal health care decisions.



Diseases & Conditions


Treatment & Services

Minimally Invasive Surgery

Ages Seen


Languages Spoken


Hospital Affiliations

Froedtert Menomonee Falls Hospital


Town Hall Health Center
W180 N8000 Town Hall Road
Menomonee Falls, WI 53051
(262) 255-2500
Get Directions
Germantown Health Center
W168 N11237 Western Avenue
Germantown, WI 53022
(262) 253-5060
Get Directions

Education & Training

St. Louis University School of Medicine - MO - Doctor of Medicine - (1999)

University of South Florida College of Medicine - Tampa - USA - Residency - (2003)

Board Certifications

Obstetrics and Gynecology

Patient Reviews

The comments are submitted by patients (or their caregivers) and reflect their views and opinions. The comments are not endorsed by and do not necessarily reflect the views of the Froedtert & the Medical College of Wisconsin health network. Learn more about our survey.

4.9 out of 5. 239 ratings, 36 reviews
Jan. 24, 2020
Dr.Diestelhorst spent a lot of time listening to the journey I had over the last year dealing with breast cancer. She asked lots of good questions and answered all the questions I had. Her assistant was also very congenial and interested in what I experienced in the last year.
Jan. 8, 2020
Dr D was very respectful and understanding in discussing a sensitive topic I am wrestling with. she presented multiple options and explained how each addressed my specific concerns and offered advice to help calm some of my uneasiness.
Dec. 27, 2019
Dr.D listens to my needs & works with me to solve any concerns I have. just love her!!
Dec. 25, 2019
she is good. treats me with respect and as a professional and a patient at the same time
Dec. 5, 2019
professional, knowledgeable, efficient, answered all questions, made us feel comfortable, very friendly
Dec. 2, 2019
I LOVE Dr. D! she is worth the wait (typically have to schedule a physical about seven months in advance or she's full). I have recommended her to MANY! I have such respect and appreciation for the outstanding physician she is.
Nov. 16, 2019
would be helpful to have more medical information and feedback with questions; some questions were very simply answered with not a lot of reasoning behind the answers
Nov. 8, 2019
dr D is the best dr, really listens to everything you have to say and tskes her time with each appt.
Nov. 4, 2019
She's amazing! Very caring. Listens. Empathizes. Always cool, calm and collected with a big reassuring smile.
Oct. 31, 2019
I really like Dr. Diestelhorst and feel she takes time to answer my questions. She also has called me in person to answer more difficult questions.
Oct. 28, 2019
Dr. Amy and all the supporting staff are absolutely amazing! I recommend her/them to everyone. She did an amazing job supporting me through my whole pregnancy. she's always there and she makes me feel super comfortable opening up about anything I am concerned about. She's very real. No one compares.
Oct. 16, 2019
she's wonderful!
Oct. 6, 2019
Amy is a very caring and knowledgeable physician
Sept. 25, 2019
Everyone at this visit ( from reception, medical assistant to doctor)was courteous, kind, thorough, respectful,and helpful.
Sept. 23, 2019
Dr D and her staff are wonderful. Good bedside. manner.
Sept. 22, 2019
I transferred to Dr Amy several years ago when we moved to the area and I feel extremely fortunate to have found her. She's overseen both of my pregnancies/deliveries and I've always felt as though I've been in the best hands possible. Pregnancy can obviously be a stressful and joyful time during life and she always made me feel comfortable and at ease. Its no wonder that she's so tough to get into - everyone that I know in Menomonee Falls sees her, and I totally get it - she's the best at what she does! Thank you Dr Amy!
Sept. 17, 2019
felt rushed
Sept. 12, 2019
Dr D is the best of the best. Her respect for me and the care she gives is top notch. I recommend her often!
Aug. 4, 2019
Dr Diestelhorst has gone above and beyond to make my husband and I feel so comfortable in what was an anxiety provoking experience for us. She put us at ease!
Aug. 1, 2019
Very knowledge and friendly. Did not rush me.
July 17, 2019
The professional, knowledgeable, and friendly demeanor made me feel both comfortable and confident with the information discussed.
July 17, 2019
She knew my history and helped ease my anxiety.
July 16, 2019
10. Dr D. is very friendly listened to what I had to say and answered my questions.
June 27, 2019
Provider was 45 minutes late for visit (delivering a baby in OB so I understand). Wish I had been told my provider was running behind when I checked in for the appointment as I left work early to make this appointment and then had to sit and wait 45 minutes. I love Dr. D, but wish I had known there would be such a significant wait time. I was taken back earlier in my wait time and made it all the way to a room before the staff member realized she had taken the wrong person back to the room.
June 13, 2019
10 It's not easy to find an OB who is familiar with RA during pregnancy and who tailors their treatment to the patient as well as Dr. D. I'm a very easy patient but I do like to be informed and proactive about my care. Many doctors don't work well with this but she does and makes me feel comfortable.
June 6, 2019
Dr Amy is the best
June 4, 2019
I love Amy! Shes absolutely great, main reason why i drive from ocnomowoc to go to town hall
June 4, 2019
the provider always makes me feel comfortable which makes it easy to ask or talk about personal health issues. She always asks how many family is doing.
June 1, 2019
she was very thorough in explaining what was going on with my pregnancy and the risks that may be involved
May 14, 2019
She seemed rushed, I wish that she had spent a little more time educating me on answers to my questions.
April 26, 2019
could not have asked for a better OB to help me through my first pregnancy. we have nothing but great things to say about Dr Amy and her team
April 12, 2019
N/A Lab wait time was 30-45 min. for 2 - minute blood draw. Not ideal, but not reflective of provider/doctor's care.
March 14, 2019
Amy is a great doctor!
March 4, 2019
Dr D is great! I don't know if shes "The Best" BUT I would definitly recommend her to all of my friends/family. Also, I answered that I waited more than 15 mins, however, I did get to my appointment early!(by about 10 mins) I waited less than 20 mins from checking in until I saw Dr. D. The nurse and I also chatted quite a but too! (The nurse was also wonderful!!)
Feb. 21, 2019
Dr. Amy is the very best!
Feb. 20, 2019
I know I can always ask her anything and she will be honest and kind. she always listens and is always willing to help.